Tag Archives: Tsukigakirei

Tsukigakirei – Anime Review

Japanese Title: Tsuki ga Kirei


Similar: Orange

My Love Story

Kids on the Slope

Karakai Jouzu no Takagi-san


Watched in: Japanese & English

Genre: Romance

Length: 12 Episodes, 1 OVA



  • Nice music.


  • No chemistry.
  • Artificial drama with little conflict.
  • The shyness is tiring.
  • CG crowds and horrendous shading.

(Request an anime for review here.)

Tsukigakirei’s unique selling point is its ‘plain’ romance free of the usual anime romance trappings. It doesn’t wish to overdramatize a relationship that isn’t the centre of the universe, as anime often does, nor does it desire melodrama to manipulate the audience’s hearts. This is a commendable idea. Sadly, in its effort to be different from the rest, it forgot to replace the elements it took out with anything compelling.

In their final year of middle school, Kotaro and Akane strike up a reserved friendship. Both wish for more than friendship, but mutual shyness holds them back and keeps their intimate conversations to text messages. If they are to progress in their relationship, they will need to get off the phones and talk IRL.

Shyness is the defining and only characteristic of this couple, which becomes tiring within a few episodes, particularly from the girl. Whenever someone asks her anything related to boys or relationships, it’s her staring at her feet going, “Um, er, ooo,” and other effort sounds we are meant to find endearing. Crippling shyness is a real condition, obviously, but not as depicted here. If she did suffer from crippling shyness, it would affect her in all areas of life. Here, however, she’s only shy when it’s convenient to have a scene go nowhere from her utter inaction and incompetence. The guy certainly doesn’t help. This shyness means they do nothing for 80% of the series and thus have no real connection, making one wonder where the attraction lies.

Kotaro and Akane have no chemistry to speak of. Again, teen attraction without chemistry is a real ‘affliction’, but not as depicted here. They wouldn’t swear undying love and do everything to stay together in the coming high school years with nothing more than hormones on which to plant their relationship. Considering they go for each other at the exclusion of all other confessions, you would imagine that something draws them together more than he’s a boy and she’s a girl. Why couldn’t the story have these two shy kids open up to each other first and then in turn develop deeper feelings? Instead, they have an immediate attraction and all they need is the courage to confess to solve everything. They develop neither as characters nor as a couple.

Because they don’t do much of anything, the story has to force artificial drama to justify a 12-episode runtime (several episodes don’t even have a purpose, such as the first, which you can skip). In one episode, a teacher confiscates Kotaro’s phone while he’s organising to meet with Akane during an excursion. His friends rope him into something the next day (of course he doesn’t tell them he’s busy), causing him to run late, but he can’t inform her without his phone. He ends up using the phone from a friend of hers. Does he explain what happened? No, that would be inconvenient. She gets all moody, accuses him of being too close to her friend (what?) and then gets over it just in time for the episode to end. I despise drama created by a lack of basic communication between characters. When the series has no actual drama to work with, it can’t pass an opportunity to force this nonsense on us, now can it? By the way, this cliché appears in most mediocre anime romances.

The side characters are forgettable and pointless, save two that have a modicum of use. One is a boy with the purpose of confessing to Akane – rejected – and one is a girl to confess to Kotaro – rejected – both of which resolve with no conflict. What’s the point? Tsukigakirei is so afraid of conflict that the confessors tell their competition of these plans and still nothing comes of it.

It’s great that you wanted to be something different, Tsukigakirei, but you don’t deserve applause for intent alone, not when you deliver a shallow relationship with no chemistry or reason to care. To those who love Tsukigakirei for being different, I suggest expanding your romance library beyond anime, where this type of story is not only common but also vastly superior. This anime has its sweet moments and I certainly wouldn’t call it terrible, yet I don’t recommend it either. I still seek a good plain anime romance. It has been a while.

Art – Low

Cheap. The tone gradients look auto filled. It’s meant to emulate watercolours, but just looks cheap. Regular use of CG crowds is hideous.

Sound – Medium

The acting is good and the music pleasant to match the romantic style.

Story – Low

Two shy high school kids fall in love and struggle to communicate. A serious lack of chemistry and motion in this relationship gives little reason to care for a tepid high school romance.

Overall Quality – Low

Recommendation: Don’t bother. Unless you are desperate for ‘plain’ romance and are unwilling to look beyond anime, Tsukigakirei is a waste of time.

(Request reviews here. Find out more about the rating system here.)


Awards: (hover over each award to see descriptions; click award for more recipients)

Positive: None

Negative: None