Japanese Title: Golden Boy
Related: Golden Boy (anime)
Genre: Comedy Ecchi Harem
Length: 104 chapters (10 volumes)
- The first few chapters made a good anime
- All garbage past the first few chapters
- Art gets lazier as the series progresses
- Messy and unfocused arcs
Golden Boy is best known for being a fun six-episode ecchi comedy about university dropout Kintaro, who travels around Japan working various jobs (coincidentally under women) to learn new skills and broaden his horizons. “Study! Study! Study!” is his motto. While browsing for something to read a while back, I came across the Golden Boy manga and added it to the list, curious to see how the source material fared. After all, I enjoyed the anime and most of the manga’s 104 chapters wouldn’t have made it to the screen.
Good heavens. What a disaster.
The premise at first is of Kintaro doing this variety of jobs, incompetent at every one of them yet his hard working nature and determination makes him a force for good after a whirlwind of chaos. These chapters, the basis for the anime, are done with in the first volume. Afterwards, Golden Boy goes into longer “arcs” with Kintaro spending more time in one location doing a single job. The education aspect quickly falls to the wayside. It pretends to keep up the premise but none of the quality in that first volume remains.
Scenarios instead devolve into being all about sex fetishes. It gets quite graphic, though not in that erotic way. I believe it was meant to be erotic but this artist isn’t good, so it looks janky and it only grows worse. Sometimes the art is intentionally bad for comedy, though you’ll be waiting for when it gets good. Basic elements such as aligning the features of someone’s face is too difficult a task here. Character sizes aren’t even consistent from one panel to the next on the same page. It’s just ugly in general. You’re unlikely to find titillation. More importantly, the writing is terrible.
Golden Boy works best in single-chapter stories, where the author can extract all humorous material of any given scenario and move on before it gets old. The longer arcs are an absolute drag to get to through and painfully unfunny. A central problem is that they put the sex first and the work experience second, whereas the single chapters did it the other way around. The sex comedy isn’t funny when it so overt. Honestly, I’m not even sure if it’s meant to be a joke half of the time.
Alright, Kintaro is going to learn to be a more seductive dancer by becoming this woman’s slave and watching her have sex. Silly premise but it’s just a gag. Wait, you’re going to repeat it over and over and over and over and over and over. (Release me from this pain.) Later arcs repeat earlier material as well. Golden Boy anime versus manga is a great lesson in the benefit of keeping it brief.
Some arcs even try to “educate” the audience on love, romance, and relationships. However, it’s the worst advice to give anyone. You may be thinking, “But Kintaro is an idiot and this is a comedy manga. Of course the advice isn’t meant to be taken seriously.” I thought that as well until I realised these are the moral conclusions of the arcs and nothing contradictory occurs.
I have never seen such a disparity in quality between adaptation and source material than seen with Golden Boy. To have one version be better than the other to some degree or vice versa is expected, but for it to be this bad is astonishing. No wonder they only made six episodes.
Art – Low
Story – Very Low
Recommendation: Avoid it. Watch the Golden Boy anime instead.
(Find out more about the manga recommendation system here.)
8 thoughts on “Golden Boy – the manga is so much worse”
Anime is very good. Too bad the manga doesn’t.
Those panels are…interesting, to say the least.
Is there a good place to read/buy this in English? I’m assuming someone translated it online only as I can only seem to find the Japanese print.
Mangadex has it all, but trust us when we say: don’t read it, it’s a waste of time and energy. Really bad.
Hoping you come back soon. Or if you don’t want to that you are happy and doing well
LikeLiked by 1 person
Same, I just started reading their reviews and am genuinely laughing. I hope the same!
LikeLiked by 1 person
i tried to read this but i found the story dull and the art horrible. and dropped after 2 chapters
I endured it to the end. Jesus, it’s so bad and get worse and worse.