Japanese Title: Yakusoku no Neverland
Related: The Promised Neverland 2nd Season (2021)
Similar: Now and Then, Here and There
Watched in: Japanese & English
Genre: Horror Mystery Thriller
Length: 12 episodes
- Tense atmosphere
- Good animation
- Shows the workings
- Gives away the mystery too early
- Villains are comical
(Request an anime for review here.)
The Promised Neverland should be an anime that you want to go in blind for, as I did, but its great mystery comes out within the first episode, so that magic is gone. Does make it easier to talk about in review.
This story takes place in an orphanage where children await adoption while under the loving gaze of Mother Isabella. The children live a peaceful life studying, helping around the house, and playing together within the safety of the walls. One day, they receive the bittersweet news that a family has selected one among them. Two of the oldest kids run after her to return her stuffed bunny, only to find horror instead as demons drop her lifeless body into a jar. She’ll keep for later.
The orphanage turns out to be nothing more than a child farm and Isabella is the shepherd. The three smartest, Emma, Norman, and Ray, begin to plot their escape. Can they take everyone?
As alluded to in my opener, I am disappointed that The Promised Neverland reveals the truth behind the orphanage in the first episode. It could have held onto that secret for another episode or two. This isn’t a case like Death Note, where seeing the story from both sides enhances the conflict and drama. See, a major problem – really, the core problem – of this anime is the bad villains. Improving this single area would alleviate several other problems, such as the too-brief mystery, which itself isn’t automatically a problem. As I said, Death Note gives it away and it works in favour of the story. Seeing the villains’ perspectives here adds little of value.
The Promised Neverland has three villains: Isabella, Sister Krone, and the demons. The demons are a shadowy entity in the background with scant minutes of airtime across the series and don’t matter beyond the catalyst for child farming. They don’t need explanation. The two women, however, are central to the plot. Isabella is the quiet, measured, plotting type who knows more than she lets on. With each passing episode, I expect some deeper revelation to her character that will explain who she is, why she is. All we get is a few seconds of backstory that barely explain anything. She is flat. Nor do we see her cunning actions enough to become a smart antagonist.
Worse is Sister Krone (subtle name, you got there). She comes in to assist Isabella, but harbours ambitions of becoming a Mother herself. She is comically bad. The performance, both in English and Japanese, is horrendous on a level up there with Jared Leto’s Joker. I don’t blame the actors for this. No performance could save her writing. It’s so over the top and manic, meant to be frightening (akin to the Joker pretending to be a loving nun) that it elicits only laughter. Her impact on the story is negligible as well. I image later seasons will bring he back for some ungodly reason.
Speaking of, I think this story would have worked better as a single season narrative. Despite remaining engaged from start to finish, I have no motivation to watch the next season unless I hear great things from a trusted source. I get the impression that future arcs will focus on the demons and the unresolved issues at the orphanage. The demons, I don’t need an explanation; the resolution of the orphanage, I expect to find repetitive.
If a single season of 12 episodes was it, complete story start to finish, I can’t imagine we would have wasted time on Krone or had Isabella remain puddle deep (one can see they are “saving her for later”). Restrictions often increase creativity and quality because there are only so many minutes on screen, so many words on the page that when the editing starts, the weak links hit the cutting room floor. If you have any familiarity with multi-season American TV shows, you will know what it’s like to see weak content added for the sake of extending the story to a fifth, sixth, seventh season when the studio renews.
So, I have vehement criticisms, yet I stay engaged to the end – why? Well, the main characters, primarily. Emma, Norman, and Ray work great. Upon first seeing their designs, I predicted their roles and arcs in the story (the energetic yet naïve one, the clever yet emotionless one, and the emo yet ruthless one, respectively). They surprise me though. Yes, they are the archetypes I predicted, but they aren’t the stereotypes I expected. Emma is naïve and idealistic, saying she would even take snitches when they escape (they suspect some kids feed information to Isabella), which is a truly dumb idea when many lives are on the line. However, she also displays moments of brilliance in both mind and heart. Remember, these three kids are supposed to be the smartest. Unlike most anime with “genius” characters that are actually dumb as bricks and only win because the author says so, these three show real brains (not in the way the demons would prefer, of course). It helps that they aren’t pitched as reality altering geniuses.
My favourite element of this story is seeing the kids figure it all out. How does Isabella know where they are at all times? Who is snitching on them? Is someone snitching? How can they escape with kids who still pick their noses and eat it? Why do the demons want them and what determines the next “adopted” child? How do they train for escape with Isabella surveying their every move? Seeing them work through this systematically is most engaging. It would have been that much better if the villains were equally engaging obstacles to the goal though.
The Promised Neverland, in the face my criticisms, receives my easy recommendation. The core of the story and its characters are sound, pulling you from one episode to the next with fast pacing and clever cliffhangers. You will want to watch just one more episode.
Art – High
The art is good, notably in animation. The demon designs are freaky, though the world itself could do with more creativity.
Sound – High
You can go with either language here. The music infuses a creepy atmosphere and I like the OP song – will probably add it to my playlist.
Story – High
A group of orphans realise that the promised land of a family is a one-way trip down a demon’s gullet in reality and the orphanage is a farm. Other than revealing the mystery too soon, The Promised Neverland delivers a tense thriller that captures your attention to the end.
Overall Quality – High
Recommendation: Watch it. The Promised Neverland is an easy recommendation from me to anyone unless child abuse in any form is too much for you.
(Request reviews here. Find out more about the rating system here.)
Awards: (hover over each award to see descriptions; click award for more recipients)
10 thoughts on “The Promised Neverland – Anime Review”
The manga is better. Also the point of the series is the tension of whether the cast will escape or not and the game of cat and mouse they play with the villains. And Isabella is not a flat villain. The fact she is human makes her more scary than the monsters.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The villain being human doesn’t make them scary. Just about every villain in every story is a human.
Yeah but the point of her us the fact that she plays a sweet mother figure but is really a cold sociopath raising her children to be eaten. She is more interesting than the generic monsters of the series. And you are aware that human beings can be scary right?
Especially someone who is suppose to love you.
Your justification for her not being flat was that she’s human – a weak argument, which I nullified. “And you are aware that human beings can be scary right?” Is the same weak argument using different words.
Her being a sweet mother figure that is actually evil is also a cliché of new stepmother and orphanage stories. It doesn’t make her deep. It doesn’t make her automatically flat either. She lacks that extra layer, however. Her backstory shown at the end was an attempt at that something extra, but when it comes at end in contradiction to her character so far, it feels tacked on. She needed real internal conflict throughout.
Great review. I agree with the point that the main characters were not just superficially intelligent. They were careful and faced failures too throughout the series. We can actually see them learn from their shortcomings.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The hope is that the next season finds a way to keep this “show the workings” going – possibly as they figure out how to survive in the wild and understand how the outside world works.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree. This will give the viewers a chance to see how they learn and interact with the world and how the trauma they experienced in the farm makes them feel in the real world.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I recently just rewatched this one myself. Have to give it to the genius direction with that first-person camera usage, as the suspense really holds up in this one. The kids are also wonderful, as you point out!
LikeLiked by 1 person