Japanese Title: Hoshi wo Ou Kodomo
Similar: Laputa: Castle in the Sky
The Place Promised in Our Early Days
Watched in: Japanese & English
Genre: Adventure Fantasy Romance
Length: 1 hr. 56 min. movie
- Gorgeous art.
- Creative environments and creatures.
- No foundations.
- Never gets going.
- Flimsy ideological conflicts.
(Request an anime for review here.)
After watching Your Name in the cinema recently, I went back to Makoto Shinkai’s previous feature-length film, Children Who Chase Lost Voices, to complete the collection. With his ability to distil human emotion into the magic of animation, it comes as a surprise to receive such a dull story and ultimately disappointing film from him.
Asuna hears strange sounds and unearthly music on her crystal radio. In her eagerness to decipher these phenomena, she stumbles into an adventure of monsters, a handsome stranger, and a lost civilisation. A school professor shows her how to reach the magical land underground.
This premise sounds very Indiana Jones, yes? Well, to best summarise Lost Voices, imagine Indiana Jones without any of the charm, wit, and action that made those films great – more importantly, fun. For a story with so many magical elements, Lost Voices has no magic to it.
I want to step back to the start for a moment. We open on Asuna in her ordinary life – as is expected for the genre – doing ordinary activities like eating food and cleaning the house, but we don’t see much of a hint at the magic in her future. In these ‘ordinary person thrust into supernatural world’ stories, great writers will include out-of-place details to draw the eye and foreshadow what’s to come, even if the character doesn’t notice. The best example of this is in Harry Potter’s first chapter.
Harry’s uncle Vernon Dursley is off to work for another ordinary day – Rowling even emphasises how ordinary the day should be in the opening line: ‘Mr and Mrs Dursley were proud to say that they were perfectly normal, thank you very much.’ However, after only a paragraph cementing their normality, the hints of extraordinary begin to drop – the never-mentioned Potter relatives, an owl in broad daylight, odd people in robes, more owls, a stranger mentioning a Potter boy, yet more owls, etc. We, the audience, stand in the realm of ordinary with Vernon yet catch glimpses of the extraordinary realm to come. This technique prevents boring the audience in the first chapter.
Shinkai did not employ this technique well.
The only real oddities in Lost Voices’ opening are the noises on the crystal radio, though since they have no meaning for some time and are distant to the protagonist, they aren’t enough to grip you. My attention faded before even reaching the Inciting Incident.
Most shocking of faults is with the…romance, if you could call it that, between Asuna and the mysterious stranger that saves her from a monster attack (not as exciting as it sounds). If there’s one aspect Shinkai knows how to do it is emotion. And yet, here we have a girl fall instantly in love – not a crush or fling – with this stranger and would do anything for him with nary a conversation between them. Did I miss a scene that established the relationship? The setup is so weak that I spent thirty minutes trying to figure out if a romance was the intention. Even with later developments, it has zero impact.
So the first act is boring, the romance is as empty as the Bebop’s bank account, which leaves us with the adventure of no charm or fun. Children Who Chase Lost Voices settles itself comfortably in the worst category of all: boring. We need characters and story to engage us below the pretty surface. This anime is better left unplundered.
Art – Very High
Gorgeous art and animation from Makoto Shinkai, as usual – those colours – though it isn’t his usual style. More Ghibli-esque.
Sound – Medium
The acting is good, but better in Japanese for some characters. Pleasant music.
Story – Low
A girl hears the sounds of a strange creature from below and investigates the legend of a lost civilisation. Lacking foundation, Children Who Chase Lost Voices gives little reason for engagement in its rather standard adventure narrative.
Overall Quality – Low
Recommendation: Don’t bother. Children Who Chase Lost Voices is gorgeous to look at, certainly, but the story is too uninteresting to be worth seeing over other anime of similar premise. I would recommend worse yet more engaging anime before this.
(Request reviews here. Find out more about the rating system here.)
Awards: (hover over each award to see descriptions; click award for more recipients)
6 thoughts on “Children Who Chase Lost Voices – Anime Review”
I recently picked this up and gave it a spin. As much as I don’t want to believe it, it’s true that this film is quite mediocre. Simply gorgeous to look at, but you’re right–I felt very little ‘magic’ in Children Who Chase Lost Voices, despite it being a story dedicated to feeling enraptured by a magical wonderland. Also, what’s up with that title? Normally I can figure these things out, but man, it seems like a loss with this one. That intervention with God or whatever at the end was very stipulating, though. “Those who seek false realities and dreams don’t deserve sight itself,” kind of thing.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I believe – just a theory – the title refers to the girl and professor chasing the ‘lost voices’ of their dead loved ones. They are referred to as ‘Children’ because it is childish to cling onto the dead when they cannot come back.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ohhh wow, that theory seems pretty solid to me. Thanks for indulging me!
LikeLiked by 1 person
What’s crazy is that if my theory is true and Shinkai had delved more into the psychological aspect of these characters’ obsession with those they lost, this could have been a great story.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I just watched this film and have to say I think you’re missing the point of it! Though I can see how you were disappointed if you were expecting an adventure movie.
I thought it was a beautiful, surreal meditation on the concept of grief and saying goodbye with some wonderful world building and a few action sequences. I liked that it refused to have a villain. Grief is the bad guy, not any of the characters, and its not something you can defeat in an action sequence!
I didnt pick up on any love story at all. They’re literally kids, right? Maybe its different in the dubbed version? I read it as she met this mysterious stranger who saved her life, and that they’re each kind, caring people. He was more of a big brother figure for the brief time he was there, wanting the best for this nice girl he’s met.